Signed in as:
filler@godaddy.com
Signed in as:
filler@godaddy.com
City Council has let the Detroit Land Bank Authority function for over a year now on an expired MoU that was written under emergency management. I urge you to reject the MoU, DISSOLVE the DLBA, and put its assets in trust for black reparations. There is a better way, and the first step is rejecting the current MoU.
I have my own grievances against the DLBA, having been a victim of their inconsistent policies, inconsistent enforcement, and inconsistent communication:
If the DLBA was doing a good job handling vacant land in Detroit this wouldn't be a debate. But as you probably know this entity is merely a shell game for private investors, a tool for manipulating the real estate market in Detroit (hoarding the city's available housing during a housing crisis), and often used to seize / amass property for solar and other large-scale developments cooked up by the Duggan administration when the Law Dept. selectively issues weaponized (and often frivolous) blight lawsuits instead of applying the rules fairly. It issues punishments for blight, while also being the single biggest owner of blight.
DLBA is also constantly in the news for scandals, such as improper environmental controls, bad title work, corrupt contractors, corrupt directors, taking back peoples' houses after they invest thousands on renovation, demolishing the wrong houses, selling houses with people still in them, selling houses with no water lines, gatekeeping who can buy parcels, sweetheart $1 downtown land deals for the Ilitch mafia, vacant houses being used for drugs & human trafficking, their website being hacked exposing auction participants to identity fraud, being sued by TV stars, etc. The City Ombudsman has recorded thousands of complaints about DLBA—the most against any single entity in Detroit.
Furthermore, the DLBA does less now than ever with their properties before auction. They used to do inspections and clean outs to the properties before sale, as well as brush clearing, tarping roofs, and periodic lawn mowing. Now, the listings aren't even put together by the DLBA, it's all farmed out to private brokers! And a year ago they even gave up on doing any title work to the parcels they own, losing the last shred of credibility they had as anything other than a pipeline to convey property to the landlord class.
The DLBA is by far the single biggest land owner, the single biggest land SPECULATOR, and the single biggest owner of BLIGHT in the city. Meanwhile, Detroit has the highest ratio of vacant homes to unhoused people in the United States: 116-to-1!
The DLBA does not get blight tickets. They do not pay the DWSD drainage fee (rain tax). They do not pay property taxes. Yet most of the property in their inventory was acquired through foreclosure of legacy Black residents who could not afford to pay those things, especially because Detroit has been systematically overassessing the lowest valued homes. The DLBA is an instrument of gentrification.
Land is the greatest, and most basic form of wealth. Malcolm X said, "land is the basis of all independence...it is the BASIS of freedom, justice, and equality." It is the essence of self determination (Kujichagulia) for any race or nation of people. And in a majority-minority city like Detroit where until recently it was known as the national capitol of Black homeownership, the ownership of already-paid-off homes holds unusual gravity; it was the beginning of self-determination, and of building generational wealth for Black Detroit. The stripping away of that mortgage-free home ownership from the Black population represents the stripping away of self determination from Black Detroit.
In Detroit today, land is mostly controlled by white people who don't live here, and the number of Black homeowners has shrunk by 100,000. The DLBA has hoarded homes foreclosed from legacy Black residents over hundreds of dollars in back taxes, then auctions them to white investors for thousands. Affluent white newcomers often get an NEZ, and pay no property taxes on those same houses that were taken from poor Black people for taxes.
The DLBA owns about ONE QUARTER of the total number of parcels in the city, and yet it is subject to no accountability or public oversight. Its board and CEOs have mostly been white, wealthy, based outside the City, and politically connected to Mike Duggan. Most of all, they are all connected to the private real estate and development industries. These are the people determining the future of Detroit's land, not the people who live on it, and this resembles feudalism.
Meanwhile, Council has a Reparations Task Force who seem to have no actual force. It's pretty obvious to me what has to happen.
All proceeds from DLBA sales have stayed with the DLBA, and not a penny has gone back to the City. That totals close to half a billion dollars they've cleared by now...and yet they clearly can't / won't maintain the blighted parcels they own. So where did the money go?
There was a recent Michigan court decision that ruled county governments cannot retain excess proceeds from foreclosure auctions, and must return those proceeds to the owners. The DLBA is also guilty of the exact same thing, yet it continues to do so with impunity. Furthermore, the DLBA also tax captures 50% of the property taxes paid each year on restored properties they've auctioned off, for 5yrs, keeping that money for its own use...this is an unaccountable quasi-governmental "authority" dealing in public assets.
The purpose of a land bank is to disburse property, not to hoard it like a dragon sitting on a pile of gold. Because of this hoarding, DLBA is by far the largest land bank in the United States. They were supposed to be able to clear titles faster than the City could, with the goal of putting parcels back on tax rolls to help the City get back on solid financial footing after the municipal "bankruptcy." But they have had major issues with clearing titles quickly (or even competently), and they have meanwhile become the largest landowner in City history. They started with 100,000 parcels in 2014, and today—11yrs later—they still own over 80,000 parcels...and all of that land is off the City tax rolls. The DLBA is a land speculator in sheep's clothing.
DLBA were also supposed to be a vehicle for rehabbing homes for Detroiters to affordably fix up and live in, but their "Rehabbed & Ready" program has not met that threshold. Instead the DLBA have served mostly as a vehicle to feed business to the local demolition industry, reducing the available housing stock, and in turn causing artificial scarcity to drive up prices of existing housing (during a housing crisis).
Some bare-minimum demands:
The school board is independent from the City, and is controlled by officials elected directly by the people. The Library Commission is similar. This is done in order to protect the considerable assets of those public institutions from potential corruption inside the City. And yet >80,000 publicly owned land parcels have no such protections or oversight?
I urge you to reject the MoU, DISSOLVE the DLBA, and put its assets in trust for black reparations under an entirely new land bank controlled by City Council, or a truly independent body appointed by, and accountable to, City Council or elected by the People.
no one would argue that vacant lighted land in Detroit was a horrible, unmanageable issue befoire the DLBA existed. But one might also argue that vacant lighted land in Detroit is still a horrible, unmanageable issue in Detroit today WITH the DLBA. The only difference is that it has now been made more profitable for certain real estate industry players; the person who has lived with blight next to their home for decades really doesn't care who owns it,
381,000 parcels of land in Detroit
As of 2023 they no longer even do title work on the properties they "own"...gave up on that and started telling people they need to do their own title search and seek legal advice on getting Quiet Title Action. And they no longer clean the house out or remove overgrowth prior to sale. So theyre saving big on that while raising the threshold of who can afford to get into this, as well as adding to the owner's burden of achieving compliance. This creates a playing field where affluent suburban landlords can still afford to play, but neighborhood folks are priced out.
This favors wealthy white investors, and increases barriers to home ownership for the low-income black people who actually live in the communities where these houses are located. So it is yet another driver of re-gentrification and of turning homeowners into renters, in areas that have been left devastated since the Dan Gilbert Rocket mortgage subprime crisis gutted our city.
in general, we object to anything that has "authority" in its name;
the DLBA hurts / manipulates property values when their properties are left blighted next to occupied homes and neighborhoods. It drags those values down.
DLBA gets some money from the City budget. Council could deny that budget allocation for the DLBA. They could also vote down the MoU and look into suing the DLBA for operating illegally without an MoU.
Detroiters For Tax Justice
P.O. Box 34040, Detroit, MI 48234
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.